Pay transparency laws are changing more than what employers put in job advertisements. Once a salary range becomes public, current employees can compare that range with their own compensation, sometimes before the company has considered what those comparisons may reveal.
That makes pay transparency both a job-posting requirement and an internal compensation issue.
The rules vary by jurisdiction, particularly for employers hiring across state lines. Before publishing a position, employers should understand which disclosure requirements apply and consider whether the proposed range is consistent with how comparable employees are currently paid.
What Must Employers Include in Job Postings?
Pay transparency requirements vary by jurisdiction, including what must be disclosed, which employers are covered, and which positions fall within the law.
In New York, employers with four or more employees generally must disclose compensation or a compensation range in covered advertisements for jobs, promotions, and transfers. The range must reflect the minimum and maximum annual salary or hourly compensation the employer believes in good faith to be accurate when the position is advertised. Certain positions performed outside New York can also be covered if they report to a supervisor, office, or other work site in the state. The New York State Department of Labor's pay transparency guidance provides additional information on covered employers and advertisements.
Employers hiring in multiple states cannot assume that following New York's requirements will satisfy the rules elsewhere.
California, for example, requires employers with 15 or more employees to include a pay scale in job postings. The state's Equal Pay Act guidance also addresses requests by current employees for the pay scale associated with their positions and related recordkeeping requirements.
Illinois takes a somewhat different approach. Since January 1, 2025, employers with 15 or more employees must include pay scale and benefits information in covered internal and external postings. Its rules also address notice to current employees when certain external opportunities are posted. The Illinois Department of Labor's pay transparency guidance explains those requirements in greater detail.
Can Pay Transparency Laws Expose Internal Pay Equity Issues?
Yes. Publishing a salary range can make existing compensation differences more visible, particularly when current employees performing comparable work are paid below the range advertised for a new hire.
Suppose an employer advertises a position at $120,000 to $150,000 while an existing employee performing comparable work earns $105,000. The difference does not, by itself, establish an unlawful pay disparity. Depending on the applicable law and circumstances, differences may be supported by factors such as experience, seniority, performance, geography, or specialized skills.
Once the range is public, however, the difference is easier to see.
Employers should consider reviewing compensation before publishing a new range, particularly when employees already perform similar work. That review should look beyond job titles and consider actual responsibilities, experience, qualifications, and the employer's existing compensation structure.
The objective is not necessarily to eliminate every pay difference. Employers should understand why material differences exist and whether those differences can be supported under applicable law and their established compensation practices.
How Do Pay Transparency Laws Apply to Remote and Multistate Jobs?
Pay transparency requirements for remote and multistate positions depend on the jurisdictions connected to the job, and those rules are not uniform.
A company advertising a position as “remote” should not assume that the role falls outside state pay transparency requirements. New York, for example, can cover certain out-of-state opportunities that report to a New York supervisor or work site. Other states apply their own requirements to remote positions.
For employers recruiting nationally, the employee's expected location, reporting relationship, and geographic scope of the posting should be considered before the advertisement goes live.
The issue is part of the broader challenge of managing distributed workforces. Our article on Remote & Hybrid Workforce Misclassification: Multi-State Tax & Wage Risk discusses how an employee's work location can create additional wage, payroll, tax, and employment obligations.
What Should Employers Review Before Posting a Salary Range?
Before publishing a salary range, employers should confirm that the range reflects what they genuinely expect to pay and compare it with compensation for employees performing comparable work.
HR and hiring managers should also understand the reasons for material differences in compensation and determine which jurisdiction's requirements apply to the position. If geography, experience, credentials, or another factor can materially change the expected compensation, the range should accurately reflect the particular opportunity being advertised.
A salary range can comply with the technical posting requirement and still raise questions inside the organization. Addressing those questions before publication puts employers in a better position to make and explain compensation decisions consistently to applicants and current employees.
For guidance on pay transparency, compensation practices, and multistate employment requirements, Bochner PLLC's Employment practice advises employers on workplace policies and compliance issues arising under state and local employment laws.
.